Skip to main content
padlock icon - secure page this page is secure

Open Access Strategisch pendelen tussen gestolde categorieën en fluïde identiteiten

Download Article:
(HTML 68.8 kb)
(PDF 113.8 kb)

Differences in health and illness between men and women appear high on the political and research agenda in Netherlands as well as in the international arena. Gender medicine is an emerging field in which attention is paid to sex and gender in health and healthcare, mostly as homogenous fixed categories of difference in particular sex difference. Such a categorical approach is useful and necessary to answer certain questions in medicine and in health care. The knowledge agenda Gender and Health (ZonMW, 2015) is one example of how categories can be put forward in constructive ways. However, we also urge health researchers to reconsider a single use of fixed categories and a single focus on sex/gender in health research. A multiple, dynamic intersectional approach aims to study intersections of sex and gender with each other and with other dimensions of difference, such as ethnicity or class. Fluid and more complex identities of people and communities and their health must be accounted for as well. An intersectional perspective offers insight in the relationship between health, identities, and society, and helps to gain an insight in health disparities between and within groups. Besides, an intersectional perspective offers insight into the unique experiences and needs of health care users, including those with intersectional invisibility. An elaborated choice for studying categories by identifying which categories are salient to which health care problem must be made. Adding intersectionality to participatory action research (PAR), which both share the basic values social justice and reflexivity, is one way to study group intersections and health(care). Besides, such research shares its basic tenets with gender-specific medicine: empowerment and contextualisation of health problems. Aim of such research is to critically study and transform practices and improve health and health care by forming alliances between stakeholders at different social locations. A participatory action research project exemplifies how we used an intracategorical intersectional approach to increase knowledge on genetic risk and reproductive options for migrant women, many of them married to their (second) cousin. We meander strategically between fixed categories and fluid identities, in which categories are recognised and used while at the same time being deconstructed and crossed-over. Using categories and forming alliances can fuel social change. In order for diversity to be genuinely transformative, joint critical reflections of all stakeholders on daily processes of normalisation and on dominant norms about gender and other dimensions of diversity can make a difference in health and care.
No References for this article.
No Supplementary Data.
No Article Media
No Metrics

Keywords: diversity; gender; gender medicine; health; healthcare; intersectionality; participatory action research

Document Type: Research Article

Affiliations: 1: Petra Verdonk is psycholoog en promoveerde in 2007 op gender mainstreaming in het geneeskundeonderwijs (UMC St Radboud). Zij werkt als universitair docent bij de afdeling Metamedica, VUmc. 2: Maaike Muntinga studeerde geneeskunde, antropologie, en epidemiologie. Ze promoveert in januari 2016 bij de afdeling Huisarts- en Ouderengeneeskunde van VUmc en is docent en onderzoeker naar diversiteit in medisch onderwijs bij de afdeling Metamedica, VUmc. 3: Hannah Leyerzapf is antropoloog en promovenda op het gebied van diversiteit in zorgteams, bij de afdeling Metamedica VUmc. 4: Tineke Abma is verpleegkundige, beleidswetenschapper, en ethica. Ze bekleedt de leerstoel Participatie en Diversiteit en is onderzoeksleider op de afdeling Metamedica, VUmc. Abma heeft veel ervaring met participatief en responsief onderzoek.

Publication date: December 1, 2015

More about this publication?
  • Het Tijdschrift voor Genderstudies is het forum voor de wetenschappelijke problematisering van sekse in relatie tot andere vormen van discriminatie en uitsluiting zoals etniciteit, seksualiteit, klasse of leeftijd. Er worden artikelen in gepubliceerd over gendervraagstukken vanuit alle relevante disciplines die een wetenschappelijke bijdrage leveren aan debatten over gender en intersectionaliteit in Nederland en Vlaanderen. Het tijdschrift is een interdisciplinair medium op het kruispunt van maatschappij-, cultuur-, geestes-, gezondheids- en natuurwetenschappen. Het verschijnt vier keer per jaar en biedt wetenschappelijke artikelen en daarnaast ook interviews, boekrecensies, discussiedossiers en opiniërende artikelen in het Nederlands en Engels. Artikelen worden dubbelblind beoordeeld door externe deskundigen.

    The Tijdschrift voor Genderstudies (Journal of Gender Studies) is a Dutch language forum for the scientific problematisation of gender in relation to ethnicity, sexuality, class, and age. The journal aims to contribute to debates about gender and diversity in the Netherlands and Flanders. The journal is an interdisciplinary medium operating at the intersection of society, culture, the humanities, health and science. The editorial staff is open to articles about gender issues from different disciplines, and also accepts English articles. As well as publishing articles, the journal includes essays, columns (short topical and polemical articles), interviews, reviews, summaries of dissertations and conference reports. Articles are subjected to a double blind peer review process.
  • Editorial Board
  • Information for Authors
  • Back issues, 1980-2012
  • Become a friend of this journal
  • Ingenta Connect is not responsible for the content or availability of external websites
  • Access Key
  • Free content
  • Partial Free content
  • New content
  • Open access content
  • Partial Open access content
  • Subscribed content
  • Partial Subscribed content
  • Free trial content
Cookie Policy
Cookie Policy
Ingenta Connect website makes use of cookies so as to keep track of data that you have filled in. I am Happy with this Find out more