Skip to main content
padlock icon - secure page this page is secure

Begging the Question as a Criticism of an Argument in Itself in Topics 8.11

Buy Article:

$48.00 + tax (Refund Policy)

At Topics 8.11 161b19–33 Aristotle lists five criticisms () which may be leveled against a dialectical argument ‘in itself’ (). The five criticisms correspond in many respects to the familiar conditions Aristotle places on syllogism and refutation. However, begging the question (BTQ)—the violation of the condition that the conclusion of a syllogism be something different () from the premises—seems not to appear on the list of five criticisms . That this omission is only apparent becomes clear once it is seen that the five criticisms are not independent but rather amount to five successive filters through which an argument may be passed before its non-genuineness (as a syllogism or refutation) is exposed. This result sheds light on Aristotle's curious insistence, in the face of the heterogeneity of his examples of BTQ in Topics 8.13, that every question-begging refutation contains a premise that is ‘the same’ as the conclusion. The fact that the five criticisms expose BTQ as a defect in syllogistic reasoning (as opposed to a mere ‘dialectical’ foul) suggests we may trace the origin of Aristotle's familiar definition of syllogism to the scoring system in the game of dialectic.
No Reference information available - sign in for access.
No Citation information available - sign in for access.
No Supplementary Data.
No Article Media
No Metrics

Document Type: Research Article

Affiliations: University of Iowa, USA

Publication date: 02 January 2016

More about this publication?
  • Access Key
  • Free content
  • Partial Free content
  • New content
  • Open access content
  • Partial Open access content
  • Subscribed content
  • Partial Subscribed content
  • Free trial content
Cookie Policy
Cookie Policy
Ingenta Connect website makes use of cookies so as to keep track of data that you have filled in. I am Happy with this Find out more