A proposed method for improving whole effluent toxicity data interpretation in regulatory compliance
Abstract:We describe three statistical models for assessing whole effluent toxicity data for National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System compliance purposes. The first model, on which the current regulatory approach is based, only considers intratest variation. The second and third models consider both intratest and intertest sources of variability. We perform a variance components analysis with reference toxicant data to show the relative magnitudes of the intratest and intertest variation. The results indicate that the third model, which is a mixed two-way ANOVA design with test crossed with concentration, is the most appropriate model. With simulations, we show that when using the first statistical model instead of the more suitable third model, the actual Type-1 error can exceed the nominal Type-1 error by a large amount. This means that tests with the first model will tend to produce an excessive number of false indications of toxicity by chance alone. We present and demonstrate a statistical test, called the reliable toxicity detection level (RTDL), that is based on the third statistical model. The RTDL is compared with other statistical measures used to determine compliance to toxicity and chemical effluent limits.
Document Type: Research Article
Publication date: 1995-09-01
More about this publication?
- Water Environment Research (WER) is published monthly, including an annual Literature Review. A subscription to WER includes access to the latest content back to 1992, as well as access to fast track articles. An individual subscription is valid for 12 months from month of purchase.
Water Environment Research� (WER�) publishes peer-reviewed research papers, research notes, state-of-the-art and critical reviews on original, fundamental and applied research in all scientific and technical areas related to water quality, pollution control, and management. An annual Literature Review provides a review of published books and articles on water quality topics from the previous year. Published as: Sewage Works Journal, 1928 - 1949; Sewage and Industrial Wastes, 1950 - 1959; Journal Water Pollution Control Federation, 1959 - Oct 1989; Research Journal Water Pollution Control Federation, Nov 1989 - 1991; Water Environment Research, 1992 - present.
- Editorial Board
- Information for Authors
- Submit a Paper
- Subscribe to this Title
- Membership Information
- Information for Advertisers
- WEF Bookstore
- Ingenta Connect is not responsible for the content or availability of external websites