Skip to main content

The Effect of Different Methods of Tree Planting on Survival and Growth of Pine Plantations on Clay Soils

Buy Article:

$29.50 plus tax (Refund Policy)


In the spring of 1952, 2 acres of Superior lacustrine clay (Ontonagon silty clay loam), comprising a part of the Ashland Branch Experiment Station, Wis., were planted to 3-0 white pine, Pinus strobus, using three different methods of ground preparation. A survey of duplicate plots 14 years later rendered the following results of paramount practical significance. Planting on the bottom of furrows: nearly complete failure, expressed in survival of less than 10% and average tree height of 4.6 feet. Planting on scalped soil: survival--52%, average height--10.5 feet, average DBH--1.2 inches, volume--24 cu. feet per acre. Planting on ridges made by two furrow slices turned inward: survival--80%, average height--16.9 feet, DBH--3.5 inches, volume--517 cu. feet per acre. In the spring of 1960, the trials were repeated on adjacent 2-acre area using slightly modified design and 3-0 red pine, Pinus resinosa, as the test plant. A record of duplicate plots, each consisting of 225 trees, was taken at the end of the 1965 growing season. Results are given in the following summary. Planting without ground preparation: survival--7%, average height--22.7 inches, total green weight (tops and roots)--4 lbs. per acre. Planting on soil rototilled to a depth of 5 inches: survival--49%, avg. height--22.9 in., green weight--182 lbs./a. Planting on ridges of two furrow slices: survival--70%, avg. height--27.9 in., green weight--597 lbs./a. Planting on ridges of disked soil: survival--77%, avg. height--29.5 in., green weight--676 lbs./a. Planting on ridges of rototilled soil: survival--67%, avg. height--32.5 in., green weight--740 lbs./a. Differences of this magnitude in the performance of trees can seldom be attainable by any other means of forest growth amelioration. The disking or rototilling prior to ridging failed to yield significant improvement in the growth of plantations and would not justify the extra cost of land preparation.

Document Type: Journal Article

Affiliations: Professor of Forest Soils, Yale School of Forestry

Publication date: February 1, 1967

More about this publication?
  • The Journal of Forestry is the most widely circulated scholarly forestry journal in the world. In print since 1902, the Journal has received several national awards for excellence. The mission of the Journal of Forestry is to advance the profession of forestry by keeping forest management professionals informed about significant developments and ideas in the many facets of forestry: economics, education and communication, entomology and pathology, fire, forest ecology, geospatial technologies, history, international forestry, measurements, policy, recreation, silviculture, social sciences, soils and hydrology, urban and community forestry, utilization and engineering, and wildlife management. The Journal is published bimonthly: January, March, May, July, September, and November.

    2015 Impact Factor: 1.476
    Ranking: 22 of 66 in forestry

    Also published by SAF:
    Forest Science
    Other SAF Publications
  • Submit a Paper
  • Membership Information
  • Author Guidelines
  • Ingenta Connect is not responsible for the content or availability of external websites

Access Key

Free Content
Free content
New Content
New content
Open Access Content
Open access content
Partial Open Access Content
Partial Open access content
Subscribed Content
Subscribed content
Free Trial Content
Free trial content
Cookie Policy
Cookie Policy
Ingenta Connect website makes use of cookies so as to keep track of data that you have filled in. I am Happy with this Find out more