Skip to main content

Approaches for Modeling Vertical Distribution of Maximum Knot Size in Black Spruce: A Comparison of Fixed- and Mixed-Effects Nonlinear Models

Buy Article:

$29.50 plus tax (Refund Policy)


Both linear and nonlinear hierarchical mixed-effects models have been used in recent years to analyze nested data sets. These types of models are effective for partitioning variance between hierarchical levels and increasing model flexibility. Models of knot size and distribution have been developed for several commercially important conifer species. Modeling knots is particularly amendable to the mixed-models approach as they are inherently nested at multiple levels including the individual whorl, tree, and stand levels. Although mixed models are effective for addressing hierarchical nesting of data, in this study we contend that improvements achieved by inclusion of mixed effects can be effectively negated with the use of an appropriate model form. This contention is presented as a case study on the development of a maximum knot size model for plantation-grown black spruce in Ontario (Picea mariana [Mill.] BSP). With a naive and simple model form, the nonlinear mixed-effects approach was significantly superior to comparable generalized nonlinear models as the root mean square error was 16% lower. In contrast, when a model form that accounted for primary covariates with a robust model form was used, difference in root mean square error between nonlinear mixed-effects and generalized nonlinear models was approximately 6%. In addition, graphic techniques for exploring distributions of random effects are presented and discussed. Mixed models are effective tools, but, as illustrated by this case study, their limitations need to be recognized and use of mixed models should not precede development of sound model forms.

Keywords: branch modeling; general; knot modeling; nonlinear least squares; nonlinear mixed effect models; residual analysis

Document Type: Research Article

Publication date: 2009-06-01

More about this publication?
  • Forest Science is a peer-reviewed journal publishing fundamental and applied research that explores all aspects of natural and social sciences as they apply to the function and management of the forested ecosystems of the world. Topics include silviculture, forest management, biometrics, economics, entomology & pathology, fire & fuels management, forest ecology, genetics & tree improvement, geospatial technologies, harvesting & utilization, landscape ecology, operations research, forest policy, physiology, recreation, social sciences, soils & hydrology, and wildlife management.
    Forest Science is published bimonthly in February, April, June, August, October, and December.

    2015 Impact Factor: 1.702
    Ranking: 16 of 66 in forestry

    Also published by SAF:
    Journal of Forestry
    Other SAF Publications
  • Submit a Paper
  • Membership Information
  • Author Guidelines
  • Podcasts
  • Ingenta Connect is not responsible for the content or availability of external websites
  • Access Key
  • Free ContentFree content
  • Partial Free ContentPartial Free content
  • New ContentNew content
  • Open Access ContentOpen access content
  • Partial Open Access ContentPartial Open access content
  • Subscribed ContentSubscribed content
  • Partial Subscribed ContentPartial Subscribed content
  • Free Trial ContentFree trial content
Cookie Policy
Cookie Policy
Ingenta Connect website makes use of cookies so as to keep track of data that you have filled in. I am Happy with this Find out more