Authors: Collier, David; Daniel Hidalgo, Fernando; Olivia Maciuceanu, Andra

Source: Journal of Political Ideologies, Volume 11, Number 3, October 2006 , pp. 211-246(36)

Publisher: Routledge, part of the Taylor & Francis Group

Abstract:

<p>Conceptual confusion has long been a source of difficulty in the study of politics. W. B. Gallie's analysis of â-˜essentially contested conceptsâ-™, published in 1956, stands as a notable effort to address this problem. He explores the normative component of these concepts and offers seven criteria for evaluating their contestedness. In the present article, we examine Gallie's framework and develop two extended applications, focused on â-˜democracyâ-™ and â-˜rule of lawâ-™. We underscore major contributions of Gallie's approach, as well as controversies it has generated. Some important critiques argue that three of his criteria are too narrow. We suggest that these critics fail to recognize that Gallie offers both a restrictive and broader definition of these criteria, and we seek to reconcile their views with his alternative definitions. Further, some accuse Gallie of naively promoting conceptual relativism by undermining standards for evaluating concepts, and others argue more sympathetically that he is too optimistic about prospects for resolving conceptual disputes. It is of course difficult to achieve Gallie's goal of promoting the reasoned discussion of these concepts, given the sharply contrasting normative and analytic perspectives that scholars bring to them. Yet his framework, augmented by the refinements explored in this article, opens promising avenues for addressing this challenge.</p>

Document Type: Research article

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/13569310600923782

Affiliations: 1: University of California, Berkeley

Publication date: 2006-10-01

More about this publication?

• Editorial Board
• Information for Authors
• Subscribe to this Title
• ingentaconnect is not responsible for the content or availability of external websites

Related content

• In this: publication
• By this: publisher
• In this Subject: Economics ,  Political Science
• By this author: Collier, David ;  Daniel Hidalgo, Fernando ;  Olivia Maciuceanu, Andra

Website © Publishing Technology. Article copyright remains with the publisher, society or author(s) as specified within the article.

• Terms and conditions
• Privacy policy
• Information for advertisers