IngentaConnect 5. Externalism and Authoritative Self-Knowledge

Author: Macdonald, Cynthia

Source: Knowing Our Own Minds, October 2000 , pp. 123-155(33)

Publisher: Oxford Scholarship Online Monographs

Abstract:

This paper defends a qualified observational model of authoritative self-knowledge, which centres on two features of ordinarily observable characteristics that help explain a subject's direct awareness of them. The first is that they are basic, in that one does not have to know of any underlying fact in virtue of which they apply when they do; and the second is that it is generally necessary and sufficient for the application of such a characteristic that it seems to a normal observer, in normal circumstances, that it does apply. The view is defended against two well-known misgivings about modelling such knowledge on observation: first, that there is a telling structural disanalogy, since observation normally involves three components, namely, the item perceived, an intermediary, non-conceptual sensation state, and a judgement grounded in that sensation state, whereas self-knowledge of an intentional state apparently involves analogues of the first and third components only, namely, a first-order content-bearing state and the second-order state that it validates; and second that, whereas the relations between a perceptual state and the item perceived are causal and contingent, those between first- and corresponding second-order intentional states are in general non-contingent, and so not merely causal.

This article is hosted on another website.

You may be required to register, activate a subscription or purchase the article before you can obtain the full text.

Proceed