The paper picks up the current renaissance of a debate on the ethical limits of science. Already decades ago, several boards of German state universities have adopted a socalled “Zivilklausel” (civil clause), which prohibits research that is directly oriented towards, or
could be exploited for, military use. Yet, the continuous and rising importance of third-party funds for universities creates more potential conflicts concerning the application of such a rule. Moreover, further German universities recently adopted civil clauses, and others are insistently
requested to do so by some of their students, researchers and labour unions. Given the importance of the issues at stake, it might not be surprising that the heated debate largely lacks a – apparently dry – legal perspective. However, the issue of the legality of such rules, whether
enacted by the state or by the university, is of high relevance for the practical outcome of the discussion, because these rules clearly affect the freedom of science guaranteed under Article 5 para. 3 of the German Grundgesetz (Basic Law). And – as this paper shows – neither the
autonomy of universities nor the constitutional goal of peace can justify this restriction. Thus, the only legal way to establish such a state or university rule would be to amend the German Basic Law. In this case, however, it would be the most recommendable (and beyond that the politically
most feasible) option to include a further sentence in Article 5 para. 3 Basic Law, which in principle allows a restriction of the freedom of science by a statute, which aims at preventing a military use of the results of university research. Still, a mere statute may not be enough to fulfil
the constitutional requirements. In order to protect the constitutionally granted and intended autonomy of science and research processes, an adequate system of case-by-case-decisions would have to be established within existing or newly installed internal university procedures and organisational
Founded in 1968. Wissenschaftsrecht (WissR) endeavors to help university administrators, lawyers, judges, legislators, scholars and the interested public in understanding the legal and administrative problems of modern research and teaching at the university level. WissR offers analyses and evaluations of existing legal norms and proposed reform bills as well as of court decisions. WissR presents relevant materials not published elsewhere and reports regularly on all decisions pertaining to the subject.
Seit 1968. Das Wissenschaftsrecht (WissR) möchte Praktikern der Universitätsverwaltung, Rechtsanwälten, Richtern, Parlamentariern und Wissenschaftlern helfen, die rechtlichen und organisatorischen Probleme moderner Forschung und Lehre imUniversitätsbereich besser zu verstehen. Das WissR bietet Analysen und Bewertungen von bestehenden Rechtsnormen, von Reformvorschlägen und von ausgewählten Gerichtsurteilen. Das WissR enthält wichtige Materialien, die sonst kaum zugänglich sind, und berichtet über die Rechtsprechung zu allen behandelten Themen. Das WissR erscheint vierteljährlich.