Writing, Interpretation, and the Book of Esther: A Detour via Browning and Derrida

Author: Carruthers, Jo

Source: The Yearbook of English Studies, Volume 39, Numbers 1-2, 1 july 2009 , pp. 58-71(14)

Publisher: Modern Humanities Research Association

Buy & download fulltext article:

Price: $21.27 plus tax (Refund Policy)

Abstract:

Although the Book of Esther is well known in Jewish tradition for its inauguration of the popular festival of Purim, it is a marginal book in Christian tradition because of the interpretative difficulties it presents to its readers. The story itself pre-empts such problems of reading and interpretation: an irreversible edict ordering the annihilation of the Jews is apparently overturned, and the reading of forgotten chronicles reverses the protagonists' destinies. This essay considers those moments when the biblical book is invoked for what it says about writing, with special focus on the literary borrowings of Robert Browning in The Ring and the Book (1868) and Jacques Derrida in `Envois' (1987). These authors' reflections on the complications of reading and suspicions about the destiny of writing not only pre-empt Esther's own colourful and varied reception history, but offer a challenge to triumphalist interpretation.

Keywords: Esther; Purim; interpretation; writing; Robert Browning; The Ring and the Book; Jacques Derrida; Envois; reception; triumphalist

Document Type: Research article

Affiliations: 1: University of Bristol

Publication date: 2009-07-01

More about this publication?

A supplement to the Modern Language Review, this journal includes articles and reviews on the language and literature of the English-speaking world. Most of the volumes published so far are 'Special Numbers', collections of between fifteen and eighteen commissioned articles on particular topics, such as the impact of the French Revolution on English writers; literature in the modern media; and colonial and imperial themes in literature.