Parametric Variation in the Semantics of Comparison: Japanese vs. English

Authors: Sigrid Beck¹; Toshiko Oda²; Koji Sugisaki³

Source: Journal of East Asian Linguistics, Volume 13, Number 4, October 2004 , pp. 289-344(56)

Publisher: Springer

Buy & download fulltext article:

Price: $47.00 plus tax (Refund Policy)

Abstract:

This paper proposes a semantic analysis of comparison constructions in Japanese which is crucially different from the standard semantics of comparatives as developed for English and related languages. The interpretation of the Japanese comparison construction is determined to a larger extent by pragmatic strategies, as opposed to compositional semantics. The syntactically provided item of comparison (the constituent accompanying yori) does not, in contrast to an English than-clause, have a degree semantics; it ultimately contributes an individual. From this item the real comparison has to be inferred. We argue that Japanese does not have English-style degree operators and probably lacks abstraction over degree variables in the syntax altogether. The proposed analysis accounts for a number of empirical differences between Japanese and English. A more general outcome is that the semantics of comparison is subject to crosslinguistic variation. A parameter of language variation is suggested as the source of the differences we observe.

Document Type: Research article

DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s10831-004-1289-0

Affiliations: 1: University of Connecticut and Universita¨t, Tu¨bingen, Japan, Email: sigrid.beck@uconn.edu 2: Tokyo Keizai University, Japan, Email: toda@tku.ac.jp 3: Mie University, Japan, Email: sugisaki@human.mie-u.ac.jp

Publication date: 2004-10-01