The Question of Natural Law in Aristotle
Abstract:Aristotle continues to be associated with natural law. Some scholars see this association as untenable; others adhere to Aquinas' reading, even if unconsciously. This article departs from both. It restores the plausibility of an Aristotelian natural law, but concludes that it is ultimately incompatible with Aristotle's doctrine. It is plausible because Aristotle does suggestively point towards it. He does so, however, in order to distance himself subtly from it. He must do so subtly because what he in fact points to is a confusion associated with the virtue of justice.
Keywords: Absolute King; Aquinas; Aristotle; Bernard Yack; Critique of Virtue; Harry Jaffa; Natural Justice; Natural Law; Nicomachean Ethics; Political Justice; Politics; best regime; democracy; divine law; justice; natural right; rule of law
Document Type: Research Article
Affiliations: Zulauf Hall 415, Dept of Political Science, Northern Illinois University, De Kalb, IL 60115., Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
Publication date: January 1, 2009