Authenticity and Cultural Rights

Author: Hendrix, Burke A.

Source: Journal of Moral Philosophy, Volume 5, Number 2, 2008 , pp. 181-203(23)

Publisher: BRILL

Purchase options

The full text electronic article is available for purchase. You will be able to download the full text electronic article after payment.

$35.00 plus tax Refund Policy

More like this?

In this: publication
By this: publisher
In this Subject: Philosophy
By this author: Hendrix, Burke A.

Content Key:

- Free

- New

- Open Access

- Subscribed

- Free Trial

Abstract:

Should states extend customized political protections to 'minority nations' or 'minority cultures'? Part of the answer depends on whether the identities at stake are merely political artifacts created or exploited by 'ethnic entrepreneurs', or whether they are 'authentic' expression of an ongoing collective life. This essay argues that the real character of groups is persistently difficult to recognize, and that 'authenticity' is a problematic notion even in the abstract. Given these uncertainties, the essay argues that states should generally treat only the claims of small and vulnerable groups as moral issues, while treating the claims of large groups primarily as political matters. The essay closes with a discussion of the legal criteria for recognizing Indian tribes in the United States, arguing that the standards used are generally plausible, if problematic in one key detail.

Keywords: AMERICAN INDIANS; CULTURE; IDENTITY; MINORITY RIGHTS; NATIONALISM; SELF-DETERMINATION

Document Type: Research article

DOI: 10.1163/174552408X328975